A Zionist helpfully explains why I am “the wrong kind of Jew”
April 4, 2018
I have received a comment on the article I put up yesterday. I am unsure whether the person who posted it – an Israeli Jew and presumably a Zionist – was aware of the irony, but in posting it, he demonstrated precisely the point the article was making.
NB: I considered concealing the name of the commenter from this screenshot, but then I thought, “What would be the point? He was happy singing out his name when making the comment in the first place, and he hardly deserves his privacy to be protected anyway.”
(Where Jacobs says “he”, he means Jeremy Corbyn.) The Jews to which Jacobs refers were the group ‘Jewdas’ and the fact that he put speech marks around the word “jews” shows that he cannot tolerate the idea that ‘Jewdas’ are Jewish people at all. They are “the wrong kind of Jew”.
Then, there is Jacobs’ use of the slur ‘Kapo’. This is a particularly malicious and dirty insinuation. For those who are unfamiliar with the term, Jacobs is accusing myself and other Jewish opponents of Israel of being prisoners in a World War II concentration camp who help the Nazi officers to run the facility, including by informing on any fellow prisoners who disobey the rules. It effectively implies a Jew who co-operates with the Holocaust. I am a Jew who dares criticise Israel’s barbaric treatment of the Palestinians, therefore I am the enemy-within. That makes me “the wrong kind of Jew” as well.
Is everyone clear just how cruel, and yes, anti-Semitic this topic of ‘undesirable kinds of Jews’ really is yet? And how vicious, bigoted, and aggressive hardcore Zionists can be, especially towards Jews themselves? Can you imagine the public uproar there would be if a Zionist had received remarks similar to these from someone in the Labour Party?
Zionism as a whole is anti-Semitic in tendency; it accepts the anti-Semitic notion that Jews cannot co-exist with gentiles (which is plainly untrue given how large the Jewish diaspora is) and so should be sent elsewhere, and its frequent intolerance of non-conformity of Jewish opinion is oppressive to Jewish people.
Zionists are not the victims in modern Britain, they are the aggressors in Palestine, and it is high time that the current establishment-narrative was exposed for the deceit it is.
TheCritique Archives 
April 5, 2018 at 8:12 am
Reblogged this on jaynelinney and commented:
aS #HAVETSTORM EXPLAINS “Zionists are not the victims in modern Britain, they are the aggressors in Palestine, and it is high time that the current establishment-narrative was exposed for the deceit it is”.
April 5, 2018 at 12:55 pm
Reblogged this on patricktsudlow.
April 5, 2018 at 4:46 pm
Reblogged this on Worldtruth.
April 6, 2018 at 11:19 am
[…] https://thegreatcritique.wordpress.com/2018/04/04/a-zionist-helpfully-explains-why-i-am-the-wrong-ki… […]
April 7, 2018 at 3:37 pm
Hello, I have written on the subject of the mural and our anti-racism discourse in general, linking to your blog post at one point. You may find it interesting. https://bit.ly/2GFDNFx
May 27, 2018 at 6:33 am
[…] A Zionist helpfully explains why I am “the wrong kind of Jew” […]
June 4, 2018 at 12:42 pm
[…] A Zionist helpfully explains why I am “the wrong kind of Jew” […]
September 26, 2019 at 4:31 am
Isn’t it funny Martin that you identify with victims of the Shoa when it suits you? At the same time taking the side of our enemies (palestinians, pro-BDS and Jeremy socialists)? Israel treating the palestinians badly? Ha! Given their declaration of principles (PA + Hamas) which denies the existence of a Jewish State in any shape or form, and welcomes the murder of Jews ANYWHERE in the world, tells me quite clearly that they are no different than the Nazi’s and YOU sir, who supports their cause are well, yes, a just like the KAPO’s of old.
September 26, 2019 at 8:46 am
“Isn’t it funny Martin that you identify with victims of the Shoa when it suits you?”
Er, excuse me? Who is the bullying, bigoted, Zionist asshole who called me a ‘Kapo’ in the first place? You are the one who invoked the Shoah, not me.
And who the hell do you think you are, trying to claim ‘possession’ of the Shoah? You are one of the most disgusting Holocaust-Manipulators I have ever had the misfortune to encounter.
–
“At the same time taking the side of our enemies (palestinians, pro-BDS and Jeremy socialists)?”
They may be YOUR enemies, they are not mine. If they are your enemies, maybe you ought to take a closer look at yourself and your brutal ethnocracy.
–
“Israel treating the palestinians badly?”
Yes. It treats them appallingly.
–
“Ha! Given their declaration of principles (PA + Hamas) which denies the existence of a Jewish State in any shape or form, and welcomes the murder of Jews ANYWHERE in the world, tells me quite clearly that they are no different than the Nazi’s and YOU sir, who supports their cause are well, yes, a just like the KAPO’s of old.”
And you are like the Nazis of old. You and your forebears have STOLEN vast quantities of Palestinian land with no recompense, and then exiled them into Gaza and the West Bank so that you can claim they don’t live in Israel and so they can’t outvote you in Elections. That is why they are your enemies, because your country dispossessed them and took their world away. They are your enemies, because you are their enemies.
All you have to do to change that is to speak out against the way the Palestinians are treated, and help to amend the colonialism of Israel. Instead, you defend it, or worse, pretend it isn’t happening. You are vile.
Also note that Hamas withdrew the call for the destruction of Israel and the Jewish people many years ago. All they are demanding is the restoration of the pre-1967 borders. What’s so wrong with that?
March 28, 2022 at 3:00 pm
“All they are demanding is the restoration of the pre-1967 borders.”
All Hamas are asking for is just the restoration of the pre-1967 borders, oh, yes, and to finish what Hitler started. But they ‘withdrew’ their demand for the genocide of an entire people (not even apologised for, just ‘withdrew’), so that’s ok then.
March 28, 2022 at 10:22 pm
Oh do shut up, you brainwashed jackass. Even if that really is what they wanted, they have absolutely no capacity to achieve it.
Pathetic coward, aren’t you? So scared of something with barely a one-hundred-thousandth the power of what defends you.
March 28, 2022 at 10:47 pm
Racist POS
December 11, 2022 at 1:17 pm
Piss off Odoni. You’re the jackass, you moron. You call me a coward, but you appear to have blocked me from replying underneath your comment; how pathetically cowardly is that? You know if that those who surround Israel had their way, they would wipe the nation and its people off the face of the earth, and do so on the basis of their religion, yet you weep salt tears when Israel defends itself. I never realised you could have a Jewish anti semite, but there you go.
December 11, 2022 at 11:19 pm
I did no such thing, Jack… sorry, I mean Mister Ass. I have no way to do it, even if I wanted to, WordPress offers me no facility to do so. If I was going to block you off, and had the facility, I would simply block you from commenting entirely. Which would be perfectly fair, seeing you’re an ignorant, paranoid liar who contributes nothing but abuse.
I mean, you’ve waited A PREGNANCY to offer this ‘reply’, and this is all you have to say? Why bother? Do you think this raging, melodramatic rant is somehow going to ‘persuade’ me that Israel isn’t a criminal Government, or that the Palestinians are in the wrong?
The strange thing is, I used to believe that when I was a kid, before I learned the full story and realised how Israel got there, and what it was doing to increase its landspace. In other words, *I* am more educated about this than you are. I also have enough of a conscience to feel disgusted that this crime against humanity is being committed in MY name without its perpetrators ever asking me.
Israel is not “defending itself.” It is stealing more and more and more land from the Palestinians, locking the displaced in the world’s largest open-air prison, and then keeping that prison massively under-supplied of the necessary basics for everyday life for its over-populated people. Of course the Palestinians fight against that, it’s a human right to do so when a people’s land is occupied by outsiders and they are oppressed on racial grounds.
You Zionist liars can never offer a realistic justification for how the theft of someone else’s country is “defending” your own. You are endorsing ethnic cleansing, and deep down, you damn well know it.
The neighbours are hostile, you say? Wow, what a revelation! OF COURSE THEY ARE! Israel is a western colony set up in one of the most important bits of Arab land! How would Americans feel if the eastern half of the States was taken over by a foreign power, which then annexed most of the western half as well, and moved most of the American population into an open-air prison made up entirely of Washington State?
Try thinking; doesn’t that hostility from the neighbours underline why Zionism and the whole Israel project is a monumental failure? Jews living in Israel are in danger? Wasn’t the whole point of Israel to create a “safe space” for the Jewish people? And yet, Jews like me, out in the diaspora, are generally SAFER than the ones living in Israel? WHAT DOES THAT BLOODY TELL YOU? Zionism has been an enormous, calamitous mistake that has badly injured the Arab world, and thus turned the Arab world against the Jewish people.
But no, you don’t care about that, do you? You just want everyone to keep telling you that Zionism was right because Zionist leaders tell you it is, and you’ll help them attack anyone who says otherwise. My position that the Palestinians must be given their freedom, if implemented, would potentially REDUCE the animosity towards Israel and thus potentially save Jewish lives. I sure ain’t the anti-Semite in this conversation. YOU are, because you support the status quo, making you an anti-Arab racist on top.
No more of your replies will be authorised. You have shown you have nothing to contribute except more violent-tempered, abusive, racist attempts to shout down inconvenient facts.