The real reason the smaller parties are pressuring Labour to table a Motion of No Confidence in the Government

December 18, 2018

by Martin Odoni

I see a lot of people on social media at the moment – especially supporters of the Scottish National Party – have still not figured out the real reason many of the smaller parties are pushing for Labour to call a Motion of No Confidence in the Government. Jeremy Corbyn did call a Motion of No Confidence in the Prime Minister last night, but only such a Motion in the whole Government can trigger a General Election.

Some are trying to argue that Corbyn is being either cowardly or indecisive, and that he lacks the courage of the leaders of the smaller parties, like Nicola Sturgeon, Vince Cable, Caroline Lucas et al. In reality, these other leaders are being no braver or more decisive at all, and nor are they, on this evidence, noticeably honest. That is a particularly sad reflection in Lucas’ case, who historically has tried hard (not always successfully, it must be conceded) to avoid fighting dirty.

Opposition leaders trying to beseige Corbyn

The leaders of the smaller parties are trying to beseige Corbyn with demands for a Motion of No Confidence in the Government

Now what a lot of people are missing is that, if a Member of Parliament in the House of Commons wants there to be a No-Confidence Motion in the Government, all they have to do is call one. There is no restriction on any Member, bar the Speaker, from calling such a Motion. They do not even have to be a party leader, let alone the leader of the Opposition, to call one (although only a Motion from the Leader of the Opposition is actually binding). So when Sturgeon, Cable et al try to insinuate cowardice or half-heartedness on Corbyn’s part, they are carefully avoiding all mention of the fact that what he is refusing to do is precisely what they are also refusing to do. And Corbyn is not being indecisive. He has decided not to table the Motion yet. Deciding not to do something differs sharply from not deciding whether to do something.

So why are the smaller parties pressing for Corbyn to ‘do their dirty work’ for them? Well, there are two reasons; –

The lesser reason is that if, or rather when, the Motion is voted down – which Tory and Democratic Unionist MPs have made clear will happen – the MP who called it gets most of the opprobrium for it.

But the second and more important reason by far is that the smaller parties all know that Labour’s policy, agreed at the Party Conference in the Autumn, is to try and force a General Election as a first resort if they can, and if they cannot, switch to trying to force a second referendum on Brexit.

At present, the smaller centrist/leftist parties mostly want a ‘People’s Vote’ (as a second referendum has been recently renamed in the vain hope that it sounds less controversial) only, but know they have no hope of forcing one without support both from Labour MPs, and from Remainers in the Conservative Parliamentary Party. Therefore, the smaller parties want to push Labour into calling a Vote of No Confidence when they know it cannot be won, so that Labour is then compelled by its own policy commitments to move on to supporting the second referendum. (If the other parties table the Motion themselves, it will not be a ‘Labour motion’ and will therefore be unlikely to trigger the policy-switch in the Labour Party.)

This has nothing to do with ‘greater SNP/LibDem courage’ or ‘Labour indecision’, and everything to do with cynical, theatrical politics, and trying to crowbar another party into co-operating. This cynicism is just as prevalent among the smaller parties as it is among Labour and the Tories.

Advertisements

11 Responses to “The real reason the smaller parties are pressuring Labour to table a Motion of No Confidence in the Government”


  1. Worth mentioning that if Labour fails to provoke a GE then ALL options are on the table, including a second referendum with or without Remain as a choice.

  2. Bobbie Carnegie Says:

    Yes – but, whatever and whoever is involved, and can be involved, besides Corbyn, in this ‘Motion of No Confidence’ Corbyn is getting all the flack for the indecisivity of the calling of the motion.

    In other words, if you’re to glean the sum total of anything presently going on in ‘Brexit-Remain parliament’ and in the streets and in the homes and abroad, and anywhere on the moon – Brexit and Remain are and is completely and entirely and without argument all the fault of Corbyn.

    When I was a tiny tot ‘passing a motion’ was something to do with me sitting on a potty, scrunching up my little angry red face, tensing my little tummy muscles while being told to do a jolly good ‘do do’.

  3. jaynel62 Says:

    Reblogged this on jaynelinney and commented:
    Want to know Why Parliaments Minions are trying to puxh Corbyn into a Vote of Mo Confidence?

    Read this from Martin Odoni, @havetstorm

    The real reason the smaller parties are pressuring Labour to table a Motion of No Confidence in the Government

  4. Fear and Loathing in Great Britain Says:

    Reblogged this on Fear and loathing in Great Britain.

  5. Paul Dodds Says:

    Your analysis is correct. Corbyn has the simple and clear task of holding his nerve until the Tories implode or explode, it makes no difference which, over Mays Brexit deal. The issue of the Labour move to a second referendum gives Corbyn the motivation not to cave in and the relish of seeing the Tories defeat themselves urges him also to maintain his steady and stable course which respects the referendum and safeguards the rights of workers many of whom showed through their vote for Brexit were disenfranchised by the Tory and Blairite politics. I voted remain and I see clearly that Corbyn way is the only way first to unite the Labour movement and then to unite the country.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: