In unwavering support of Mike Sivier

May 3, 2017

by Martin Odoni

I cringe when politicians pontificate about ‘standing shoulder-to-shoulder’ with allies, but I feel it is my turn to do likewise.

Mike Sivier of the Vox Political blog is standing for election on the 4th of May – May The Fourth Be With You tomorrow, Mike – as the Labour Party candidate for Llanbadarn Fawr council. Mike has recently come under attack from several directions over supposed ‘anti-Semitism’ in his work.

Now, although I am an atheist and, truth to tell, quite dismissive of religion, I am ethnically Jewish by birth. I would therefore always be keenly reluctant to defend, or associate in any way, with anybody who has an unapologetic history of anti-Semitism. Intermittently through my life, I have been the victim of anti-Semitic abuse myself. Therefore I would not wish to defend Mike if he had such a history. But I am very confident he has no such history, and I one-hundred-per-cent back him against these accusations.

I have read the blogposts over which he has been criticised by the Campaign Against Anti-Semitism, (CAA – unofficial real name; Campaign Against Anyone Perceiving The Reality Of Modern Israel) and I can state without hesitation that Mike did not write the remarks of which he is accused. I especially dismiss the inflammatory false quotation that Mike supposedly “believes that there is a ‘conspiracy’ by Jews.”

On Labour’s local Facebook page for Llanbadarn Fawr, I wrote the following, but I feel I should reshare it now in the hope that more people get to read it; –

This attempt to accuse Mike Sivier of anti-Semitism is yet another in an unending list of examples of the term being used as a weapon. I am ethnically Jewish by birth (though not religious). I have been following Mike’s blog for years and frequently correspond with him. I can state categorically that I have never read anything he has written that could be sensibly construed as ‘anti-Semitic’. With good reason, he is critical of Israel for its treatment of Palestinian Arabs – as indeed am I – but that lazy tendency to call opposition to Israel ‘anti-Semitism’ would be akin to calling opposition to Nazi Germany in the 1940’s ‘anti-Aryanism’.

I am always disgusted by the use of anti-Semitism accusations as a weapon. In a sense, it is as racist to use the term in this way as it is to be anti-Semitic in itself. It reduces an entire ethnicity to a tool to be used whenever a person’s silence is desired. Reducing an entire people to a usable tool is to make them less than the person using them. What could be more racist than that?

I ask readers to pay particular attention to that second paragraph. I mean it, and I say it with both hurt and anger. Any person who uses the word ‘anti-Semitism’ to silence criticism of Israel or Zionism is himself/herself anti-Semitic. Even if the accuser is also Jewish, he/she is still being anti-Semitic (yes, it is possible for people to be prejudiced against their own race; ironically, the CAA is actually an anti-Semitic organisation).

My ethnicity, and the ethnicity of every Jew living or dead, is part of who we are as human beings. It is not a crude debating tool to be cynically manipulated to silence inconvenient counter-arguments, be they voiced by Mike Sivier, Max Blumenthal, Naz Shah, Ken Livingstone, or any of a thousand other honest opponents of Israel. Anyone who uses an ethnicity as a tool or a weapon is putting that ethnicity in the service of themselves, making it less than other people. That is racism. Use false accusations of anti-Semitism, and you are as racist as an explicit anti-Semite.


3 Responses to “In unwavering support of Mike Sivier”

  1. Sophia.George 💋 Says:

    Reblogged this on Site Title and commented:
    Well written- I fully agree with all points you have made.

  2. Florence Says:

    100% agree. As someone who is also standing for election, I have taken all my social media off line because I am literally afraid of these smears being repeated across Wales. Mike has stood up to these terrible allegations with dignity. I’m glad he has supporters who can speak from the heart.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: